Photo: epantha / iStock / Getty Images
New York has decided to pause the implementation of the All-Electric Buildings Act, initially set to take effect on January 1, due to ongoing legal challenges. The act, often referred to as the "Gas Stove Ban," applies to newly constructed buildings under seven stories and is part of the state's 2019 climate law. Trade groups have filed an appeal, arguing that the all-electric mandate infringes on federal law. The state will wait for a court decision before proceeding with the implementation.
Environmental advocates are concerned about the delay, arguing it hinders New York's climate progress. Katherine Nadeau, Deputy Executive Director of Policy and Programs at Environmental Advocates NY, stated that the delay "will keep us stuck in a fossil fuel past we can’t afford" and urged Governor Kathy Hochul to push for clean energy solutions.
Governor Hochul, addressing concerns from 19 state assemblymembers, emphasized affordability and grid reliability as key considerations. Assemblymember William Conrad, leading the petition, expressed the need for a reassessment of grid reliability and cost impacts. Hochul has acknowledged these concerns, stating her focus on affordability for New Yorkers.
Despite the pause, the law's phased approach aims to ensure grid readiness. According to Canary Media, the law initially affects smaller buildings, with larger ones exempt until 2029. The Department of Public Service has proposed exemptions if grid upgrades delay projects by over 18 months.
Analyses suggest that all-electric buildings are more affordable long-term, despite higher initial costs. A 2024 state report indicates a payback period of 10 years or less due to efficient appliances. A 2025 study by Switchbox found potential savings of $12,050 over 15 years for all-electric homes compared to those using gas or propane.
The New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) has assessed the grid's capacity to handle electrification. While some concerns exist, NYISO's industry-standard approach indicates sufficient resources to meet demand through 2034. The debate continues as stakeholders weigh the benefits and challenges of transitioning to all-electric buildings.